Sounds like "Comfort" mode would be about the same then, I find that the Trophy set that way also wallows a little in curves with uneven paving. I was wondering how the longer travel suspension would soak up irregularities. The people that I know that ride R1200GS' think they ride really well. Thanks for all the info.
The suspension on the new Tiger 1200 is nothing like the Trophy's, even the SE's. The Tiger 1200 has a semi-active suspension that modifies the compression damping dynamically based on the road surface, firming up to the maximum set by the rider. The Trophy SE is a static compression setting and the electrics simply change the rebound damping, which just changes how the bike "feels" but doesn't really do much of anything (rebound damping changes how fast the wheel returns to the ground after being compressed; obviously, that doesn't modify much of anything with regard to soaking up bumps -- but it makes for scalloped tires if it's constantly in "comfort" and the rider doesn't weigh very much).
I'm surprised it didn't feel a lot faster... it's almost 200lbs lighter, and the engine is 9hp more powerful. Every review I read mentioned it felt more zippy than the prior Tiger 1200, which was already quite a bit faster than the Trophy.